Are You a "Good" Sinner or a "Bad" Sinner?

2 Cor. 6:16-7:1; Luke 7:11-16.*

The Seventeenth Sunday after Pentecost, known as the Third Sunday of Luke.

The Third Sunday after the Holy Cross; also the Holy Apostle James Alpheus (the Lesser); our Venerable Father Andronicus and his wife, Athanasia; our Righteous Forefather Abraham and his nephew, Lot; and the Holy Martyr Denis, Bishop of Paris.

Return to

2:02 AM 10/10/2011 — Certainly the most impressive miracles and signs performed by our Lord in the Gospels are those in which he raises someone from the dead: the Synagogue leader’s daughter, the centurion’s manservant, his own relative, Lazarus, and this unknown person of whom we read today, a young man being carried to his grave, accompanied by his grieving mother. It’s a sad scene St. Luke paints for us, which has a happy ending when Christ miraculously restores life to the dead man. It’s a testimony to our Lord’s divinity—for who can raise the dead except God?—as well of his power over death, which he would proclaim most perfectly in his own resurrection.
     But the Scriptures speak a metaphorical language that is often foreign to modern ears. For this is more than just a story about Christ’s divinity and his power over death; it is a lesson about sin. All references to death in the Holy Gospel are references to sin. For the Evangelists, sin and death are the same thing: where one is mentioned, the other is understood. Just as physical death envelops the body in darkness, so sin envelops the soul in darkness; which is why St. John describes Christ as “...the light [that] shines in the darkness” (John 1:5). Darkness is the quintessential evil for St. John: sin, error, heresy, disobedience, licentiousness, covetousness, death itself, are all part of the world of darkness in the Holy Gospels. And Christ is that light which shines forth in the darkness, in the midst of prevailing error, and makes it disappear. “Walk as a child of the light,” says our Lord again and again, meaning, “Walk apart from sin.” Because the person who walks in the way of sin must walk in darkness; he prefers the darkness. It is the darkness that hides his sinful deeds from the eyes of others. Sinful deeds are committed in darkness because they must be secret. When Christ admonishes us to walk as children of the light, he is saying, “Have no need for secret acts.” Everything you do, no matter how private, should be able to be seen without scandal.”
     Certainly everyone is entitled to privacy; and all of us have private parts of our lives, our jobs, our marriages, which are not intended for public view. Most of the time it’s a question of appropriateness or modesty. But when a person develops a part of his or her life that must be kept secret because it contradicts the life he or she lives in public—because it would cause a scandal for those who know him—such a person must ask himself if it should be at all.
     Now, everybody sins. St. Peter says in his Second Epistle that anyone who says he is not a sinner is a liar. I sin, you sin, we all commit sins. But St. John Chrysostom explains to us that, even though we all sin, it is possible to distinguish what he calls the “evil sinner” from the “good sinner”, as odd as that may sound—and I’ve quoted this to you before. The “good sinner”, he says, when he is told he has sinned, reacts with sorrow and begs forgiveness. The “evil sinner”, when his sin is discovered, reacts with indignation, protesting that his privacy has been violated. And over the centuries, no excuse has been used more to defend sinful actions when they are brought to light then the so called right to privacy. The very quintessence of evil in our own society, abortion, was judicially legislated into the law of our country in the Roe vs. Wade decision not because the court said human life was not precious, not because it said abortion was good, but because of what they called the right to privacy. It never occurs to the proponents of this form of murder to ask: If it’s not wrong, why is it so important to protect its privacy? Why must it be done in darkness apart from the knowledge of others if there’s nothing wrong with it?
     When Jesus raised the dead man to life as we read in the Gospel lesson, St. Luke added the line, “Then fear came upon them all, and they glorified God...” (Luke 7:16). It sounds like a contradiction, but it isn’t. Fear came upon them because they realized that there is no darkness that can shut out the light of Christ, not even the darkness of death; that the dark rooms that they held in their hearts could be penetrated by Christ. But they glorified God in this because they knew that once a man leaves the darkness and enters into the light—once his sin is exposed and dealt with—then he is free. He is free to walk in the light without shame, no longer having to lurk in the shadows, hiding a part of himself from the eyes of his neighbor, forced by his own choice to live a double life. For then does he realize that whatever pleasure or fulfillment he thought he had in the darkness, it cannot compare to the joy, the rest, the peace given to his soul when there is nothing to hide, when the light can shine brightly on his whole self without cause for shame. No wonder they said of him, “A great prophet has risen among us”; and, “God has visited His people.”

Father Michael Venditti

* Due to the "Lucan Jump," the Gospel read today is that for the 20th Sunday after Pentecost. Cf. the note appended to the Fifteenth Sunday after Pentecost.